﻿From: Allen Laird
Sent: Thursday, August 20, 2026 00:24
To: Lisa Shenton <shentonl@ccsd161.org>
Cc: 'tavennerj@ccsd161.org' <tavennerj@ccsd161.org>; 'strongt@ccsd161.org' <strongt@ccsd161.org>; 'smalll@ccsd161.org' <smalll@ccsd161.org>; 'williamsd@ccsd161.org' <williamsd@ccsd161.org>; 'Eileen Holden' <holdene@ccsd161.org>
Subject: RE: Records request including emails dated Aug 14 and 17

See attached PDF.

SUBJECT
Article on the November 2026 supplemental levy, provided in advance of publication
------------------------------------------------------------------------

Lisa Shenton, Clerk of the Board of Trustees
Clark County School District No. 161
43 West 2nd South
Dubois, Idaho 83423

Dear Ms. Shenton:

Thank you for the response of August 20 and for the documents that came with
it. It was thorough and it was prompt, and I want to acknowledge that before
anything else.

Attached is an article I intend to publish before the November election. I am
sending it to you now, well in advance, so that the Board sees it before the
public does and has time to respond if it wishes to.

WHAT THE ARTICLE SAYS

It reports that I asked three questions and that two of them were answered.
It states that no bus was purchased in the last three budget years but that
money was set aside toward one in a bus depreciation fund. It states that the
bus barn was paid from ESSER III and Forest Funds, that the total was
$351,685.02, that this matches the District's own check registers to the
penny, and that neither fund belongs in a levy report. It quotes Superintendent
Holden on why a small district's per-student cost runs high, and it credits
the District for producing records inside the time the law allows.

The article also reports the one question that came back without a record: how
the figure of $250,000 was arrived at. Your response explained how the amount
is divided among three categories and why the division changed this year. It
did not describe an analysis, worksheet, or calculation behind the total
itself, for this resolution or for the two before it.

That is the substance of the piece. It does not allege that anyone broke a
law, misused money, or acted dishonestly, and it says so plainly.

TWO THINGS THE BOARD MAY WANT TO CONSIDER

First, if a budget analysis or worksheet supporting the $250,000 figure does
exist and was simply not located, send it and I will publish it alongside the
article, in full and without comment.

Second, the article discusses Rockland School District No. 382 in Power
County. Rockland has roughly twice our enrollment in one building, spends less
per student than we do, and publishes the share of its secondary students
taking dual credit and Advanced Placement courses. Its own materials describe a
community that has passed bonds and levies repeatedly over many years. In 2021
it asked its patrons for $290,000 and received 95 percent support.

I raise it because it suggests something worth the Board's attention: a
community will fund a specific request. Idaho Code 33-802C makes the amounts
disclosed on a supplemental levy ballot binding on how the money is spent,
which means a specific ask is enforceable as well as persuasive.

My own vote against the last levy was not a complaint about the cost. It was
that the District should have asked for more than $250,000 if it wants this
school to improve and grow, and never explained why it did not.

There is still time before this ballot is printed, and a spring election exists
if the Board would rather bring back a request with the reasoning shown.

CORRECTIONS

If any fact in the attached article is wrong, I will correct it and say so.
Send the record that shows the error and I will issue a corrected version.

I am not asking for a meeting and will not be attending to speak. Any response
in writing, by email or by mail, will be received and considered, and will be
published in full if the Board wishes it to be.

Respectfully,

Allen Laird
Kilgore Resident, Clark County
PO Box 1791
Idaho Falls, Idaho 83403-1791
allen_laird@outlook.com
