﻿From: Allen Laird
Sent: Saturday, August 22, 2026 13:10
To: Lisa Shenton <shentonl@ccsd161.org>
Cc: tavennerj@ccsd161.org; strongt@ccsd161.org; smalll@ccsd161.org; williamsd@ccsd161.org; Eileen Holden <holdene@ccsd161.org>
Subject: RE: Records request including emails dated Aug 14 and 17

SUBJECT
Revised draft article, with new material on what this levy costs a household
------------------------------------------------------------------------

Lisa Shenton, Clerk of the Board of Trustees
Clark County School District No. 161
43 West 2nd South
Dubois, Idaho 83423

Dear Ms. Shenton:

Attached is a revised draft of the article I sent the Board on August 20.
It is longer than either earlier version and it is still a
draft. I have not published it, and I am sending it now for the same reason as
before: so the Board sees it before the public does and can respond if it
wishes.

WHAT IS NEW SINCE THE LAST VERSION

The draft now works out what this levy actually costs a household, which none
of the earlier versions did.

Idaho Code 63-602G exempts the lesser of half a home's value or $125,000 for
the family living in it. A home assessed at $200,000 is therefore taxed on
$100,000. At the rate charged in tax year 2025, that home paid about $82 a year
toward this levy, or roughly $6.87 a month.

The draft also works out the other direction. Collecting at $123.07 per
$100,000, the rate printed on the ballot itself, would cost that same home
about $10.26 a month rather than $6.87. A difference of $3.39. Across the
District that is roughly $82,500 more a year.

For comparison, the school resource officer the District has told me it must
begin funding in 2027 costs $67,745 a year. Spread across the District's
taxable value, that is about $2.78 a month on a $200,000 home.

I set those figures out because the Board's stated reason for holding the levy
at $250,000 was the cost to taxpayers. The draft reports that reason in the
Board's own words and then places these numbers beside it. Readers can weigh
both.

The draft also adds three things the District's own papers raise: the State's
finding that English Learner growth here does not meet target while the ESL
role is one of four titles held by a single position; the absence of any
published figure for how many students take dual credit or Advanced Placement
courses; and athletics, measured against the standard the District's own
handbook sets.

WHAT HAS NOT CHANGED

The draft still credits the District for the bus depreciation fund, for the
federal funding and competitive bidding of the bus barn, and for producing
records within the time the law allows. It still states plainly that no one is
accused of wrongdoing. It still tells readers that voting yes is a reasonable
position and gives the case for it.

MY QUESTIONS REMAIN OPEN

Whether the Board intends to review the statement that the existing levy
"currently costs $123.07 per $100,000" before ballots are printed. The State's
own report puts the rate at $82.44.

And whether any analysis, worksheet, or calculation exists behind the $250,000
figure. If one is located, send it and I will publish it in full.

If any fact in the attached draft is wrong, tell me and I will correct it and
say so, as I have done four times already.

I expect to publish in late September or early October. Anything the Board
sends before then will be included, in full, alongside my own account.

Respectfully,

Allen Laird
PO Box 1791
Idaho Falls, Idaho 83403-1791
allen_laird@outlook.com

Attachment: "The One Question They Could Not Answer," draft, 18 pages
