﻿SUBJECT: Request for review under sections 33-116 and 33-119, Idaho Code - Clark County School District No. 161

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Allen Laird
1525 Kilgore Ln
Dubois, ID 83423-5036
allen_laird@outlook.com
986-999-2338

5 September 2026

Idaho State Board of Education
650 W State Street, 3rd Floor
PO Box 83720
Boise, ID 83720-0037

RE: Request for review of Clark County School District No. 161 and Clark County
Jr./Sr. High School under sections 33-116 and 33-119, Idaho Code

Members of the Board,

I live in Kilgore, in Clark County, and I vote here. I am writing to ask the
Board to look at School District No. 161.

Section 33-116, Idaho Code, places every school district in this state, mine
included, under the supervision and control of this Board. Section 33-119
authorizes the Board to set accreditation standards and to withdraw accreditation
from a secondary school that has "failed or neglected to conform" to them. I am
asking the Board to determine whether this district and this high school conform,
and to say so either way.

I am not asking the Board to close a school. I would rather it never came to
that. I am asking whether anyone at the state has looked, and what was found.

WHAT PROMPTS THIS REQUEST

Each item below is drawn from a document published by the district or the state.
Copies accompany this letter.

1.  Clark Jr./Sr. High School was identified as Comprehensive Support and
    Improvement - Underperforming in November 2022, a designation the state made.

2.  The district's own improvement plan sets its goal for eighth grade
    mathematics proficiency at 30.0 percent. That is the goal, not the result. It
    has stood unchanged across three consecutive plan years.

3.  The same plan leaves its college and career readiness measure blank.

4.  The state's report card records three findings of "Does Not Meet State Goal
    or Target" for this district, including English learner progress.

5.  The district's board minutes for October 2021 record a motion approving the
    continuation of an alternative authorization because "an emergency condition
    still exists in filling the position of Secondary math teacher."

6.  The district's junior-senior high handbook sets out the subject areas
    required for graduation and names each teacher with the subjects they carry.
    No foreign language appears in either list, in a district reporting that
    thirty percent of its students are English learners.

7.  The minutes of March 2019 record the board being told, of its own strategic
    plan, that "some areas do not have the goals from the past available."

8.  In August 2022 the minutes record that the improvement plan needed goals and
    that the superintendent asked the board what it would like to add. In
    September 2022 they record that the plan "was updated to comply with the
    regulations of the grant."

9.  I have reviewed all one hundred and sixty-one sets of board minutes the district
    has published, covering January 2016 to July 2026. In the last five years and
    approximately sixty meetings, I can find no record of this board asking the
    district for an analysis, a costed proposal, or a plan to raise any measure
    of student achievement.

WHAT I ASK THE BOARD TO DETERMINE

a.  Whether Clark County Jr./Sr. High School conforms to the accreditation
    standards established by the Board under section 33-119, Idaho Code, and if
    it does not, in which respects.

b.  Whether the district's improvement plans for the years 2016 through 2026 met
    the requirements of section 33-320, Idaho Code, as that section read in each
    of those years, and whether any of them were reviewed by the Board or by the
    State Department of Education.

c.  Whether the goals set in those plans, in particular a mathematics
    proficiency goal of 30.0 percent held constant for three years, satisfy the
    requirement that a plan set clear and measurable goals for student outcomes.

d.  Whether the district has complied with the requirement that the board of
    trustees monitor progress toward the goals in its plan, and whether that
    progress has been considered in the superintendent's evaluation as the
    statute requires.

e.  Whether the supervision contemplated by section 33-116, Idaho Code, has been
    exercised with respect to this district at any time in the last ten years,
    and in what form.

f.  Whether this district qualifies to apply for alternative student success
    measures under section 33-320(4), Idaho Code, given that it reports
    fifty-nine percent of students from low income families, thirty percent
    English learners, seventeen percent with disabilities and five percent
    homeless,
    and whether it has ever been advised of that option.

WHAT I AM NOT ALLEGING

I am not alleging that anyone has broken a law, misused public money or acted
dishonestly. I have found no evidence of any of those things and I say so
plainly. Nothing in this letter should be read as an accusation against any
individual.

What I am describing is a district that has been designated as underperforming by
the state, that sets modest goals and does not move them, and whose board leaves
no record of asking for anything better. Whether that amounts to a failure to
conform to the Board's standards is a question for the Board, not for me. I am
asking that the question be answered.

WHY NOW

The district has placed a supplemental levy of $250,000 per year for two years on
the ballot of 3 November 2026, beginning in fiscal year 2028. Section 33-320,
Idaho Code, as amended this year, requires a strategic performance plan beginning
in the 2027-2028 school year, quarterly public review of progress by the local
board, and escalating involvement by the state where progress is not shown.

The first year of that new obligation and the first year of this levy are the
same year. This seems to me the right moment for the Board to look, while there
is still time for its findings to shape what happens rather than to record what
already did.

I would be glad to provide any of the underlying documents, or to speak with
Board staff. Every document I have relied on is a public record and I have made a
complete copy available to anyone who asks.

Respectfully,

Allen Laird
Clark County, Idaho

Enclosures: index of source documents
