﻿From: Allen Laird
Sent: Wednesday, October 21, 2026 12:14
To: 'Spencer Barzee' <sbarzee@sde.idaho.gov>
Cc: 'Alica Holthaus' <aholthaus@sde.idaho.gov>; 'Kristine Moriarty' <kmoriarty@sde.idaho.gov>
Subject: RE: Clark County - Response to Mr. Laird

SUBJECT
RE: Clark County - Response to Mr. Laird - corrections to my letters
------------------------------------------------------------------------
To: Spencer Barzee sbarzee@sde.idaho.gov
Cc: Alica Holthaus aholthaus@sde.idaho.gov;
      Kristine Moriarty kmoriarty@sde.idaho.gov
------------------------------------------------------------------------

Dr. Barzee,

In my email of October 19, I wrote that every section I cited matched the current text on legislature.idaho.gov. That was not fully right, and I want to correct it before anyone else has to.

While preparing my article and my letter to citizens, my own review found four errors in my September 5 letters. They may be what the Department's October 19 response meant when it said that some of the cited statutes, requirements, and references were "either inaccurate or did not align with current law":

1. I described section 33-320 as "amended in 2026." The former section was repealed this year and a new one written in its place.

2. I wrote that the statute requires progress on the plan to be considered in the superintendent's evaluation. The current text does not say that.

3. I asked for section 33-911 distributions from 2015-2016 on. That section was added in 2023.

4. I cited section 74-103(4) for the duty to state the basis for a denial. That duty is now in section 74-103(5), and its words are "statutory authority," not "exemption."

Three of these came from working from earlier versions of the law instead of rereading the current text: the former section 33-320 once tied plan progress to the superintendent's evaluation, and section 74-103 numbered that subsection (4) until 2022. The third, the request for section 33-911 payments, I simply did not check.

I also paraphrased the Department's response too loosely. It says the Department "has not exercised any extraordinary supervisory authority" under section 33-116. My email left out "extraordinary."

If the Department had other errors in mind, I would still like to know which ones, so I can correct them too. My article will report these corrections. The other questions in my October 19 email still stand.

Respectfully,

Allen Laird
1525 Kilgore Ln
Dubois, ID 83423-5036
allen_laird@outlook.com
986-999-2338

From: Allen Laird
Sent: Monday, October 19, 2026 21:52
To: 'Spencer Barzee' <sbarzee@sde.idaho.gov>
Cc: Alica Holthaus <aholthaus@sde.idaho.gov>; Kristine Moriarty <kmoriarty@sde.idaho.gov>
Subject: RE: Clark County - Response to Mr. Laird

SUBJECT
RE: Clark County - Response to Mr. Laird - five points still open
------------------------------------------------------------------------
To: Spencer Barzee sbarzee@sde.idaho.gov
Cc: Alica Holthaus aholthaus@sde.idaho.gov;
      Kristine Moriarty kmoriarty@sde.idaho.gov
------------------------------------------------------------------------

Dr. Barzee,

Thank you for the Department's response of October 19, 2026, and for the documents behind its links. I will publish the response and those documents in full with my article, so that readers can see the Department's answers in its own words.

Five points remain open. I ask them in writing so that the answers can be published as well.

1. Which statutes were inaccurate. The response says that "some of the cited statutes, requirements, and references were either inaccurate or did not align with current law," but does not say which. I have compared every section I cited against the current text on legislature.idaho.gov: sections 33-116, 33-119, 33-320(4), (6), (8)(a) and (17), 33-911 and 74-102(10). Each matches. Please identify each statute, requirement or reference the Department considers inaccurate, and what the correct one is. If I have made an error, I will correct it publicly, as I have offered from the start.

2. The matrix. Section 33-320(6) requires the State Board of Education to adopt the matrix "no later than September 1, 2026." The response says the matrix "has not yet been utilized," but not whether it was adopted. The Department's own email to superintendents of September 18, 2026 attached a "Workbook Matrix for Strategic Plan - 1339" and referred to districts "with an active Strategic Plan Matrix." Please send that workbook and the presentation attached to the same email, and say whether that workbook is the matrix adopted by the State Board under section 33-320(6), and if so, on what date. I am asking the State Board separately for its record of adoption.

3. Superintendent evaluations. The response says that "annual audits conducted for Clark County School District indicate that the district is compliant with applicable superintendent evaluation requirements." I can find nothing on superintendent evaluations in the district's audited financial statements for the year ended June 30, 2026. Please identify the audit, and the page, on which the Department relies. The district has not answered my own request of August 23, 2026 for the dates of those evaluations.

4. The plans reviewed. The response says the State Board "received and reviewed" the district's plans "for the years 2019 through 2026." The State Board's written statement of September 18, 2026 says that no plan was located for 2021 and no review record for 2021. Please say which is correct for 2021.

5. Two questions not yet answered.
   (a) Whether a mathematics proficiency goal of 30.0 percent, held for three years, satisfies the requirement in section 33-320(3)(a) that a plan "set clear and measurable goals for student outcomes." The response explains that goals need not change every year. That was not the question.
   (b) Whether the district has ever been advised that it may apply to use alternative student success measures under section 33-320(4).

So that my own account is accurate, I will report three things the response confirms. The Department "has no records indicating that Clark County School District No. 161 has been notified that it was not demonstrating progress toward the goals" in its plans. The Department has not exercised its supervisory authority under section 33-116 over this district in the last ten years. And whether a board monitors progress toward its own goals "is not a function performed by the Department, nor is the Department aware of any state agency that routinely collects or reviews such information." If I have misread any of these, please tell me.

I will also report what the response and its documents say in the district's favor: that the high school met the state's exit criteria in English language arts, that its mathematics proficiency rose 7 percent in a year, that the Department's coordinator wrote it would have met all exit criteria had 2026 been a re-identification year, and that it is accredited through June 30, 2032.

Where these points call for records, I request them under the Idaho Public Records Act, sections 74-101 through 74-126, Idaho Code, as electronic records only, in their native format where one exists, sent by email. Nothing printed, scanned from paper, or mailed. If a record exists only on paper, please tell me before any work is done on it. Section 74-102(10) provides the first two hours of labor and the first 100 pages without charge. If any charge would apply beyond that, please itemize it and send it to me before the work is done. No chargeable cost is to be incurred without my written agreement first.

Respectfully,

Allen Laird
1525 Kilgore Ln
Dubois, ID 83423-5036
allen_laird@outlook.com
986-999-2338

From: Spencer Barzee <sbarzee@sde.idaho.gov>
Sent: Monday, October 19, 2026 14:31
To: allen_laird@outlook.com
Cc: Alica Holthaus <aholthaus@sde.idaho.gov>; Kristine Moriarty <kmoriarty@sde.idaho.gov>
Subject: Clark County - Response to Mr. Laird

Mr. Laird,

Attached is the response to your inquiry submitted to the Idaho State Board of Education and the Idaho Department of Education.

Please let me know if you have any further questions.

Thank you,

Spencer

Dr. Spencer Barzee, Ed. D
Deputy Superintendent
Idaho Department of Education
